"Wild Horse Nine" Review
OP-ROB RATING: LEGEND
Martin McDonagh’s 2008 black comedy “In Bruges” is, for me, an all-timer. There is something irresistible about the depressing but somehow giddy plot, and the electric banter between Brendan Gleeson and Colin Farrell in the lead roles; plus an unforgettable Ralph Fiennes supporting performance. It’s the type of movie that I’ll rewatch anytime. We all have this shortlist of imminent rewatchables. “In Bruges” is kind of an outlier within my own list. For one, it is from a director whose work is generally not to my liking. Neither of McDonagh’s most acclaimed works were keepers for me (“Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri” and “The Banshees of Inisherin”). More importantly, “In Bruges” has several scenes that I find wholly unnecessary and distracting, such as the entire house party sequence with the prostitutes and the dwarf. It is not a perfect movie. Nevertheless, it holds a special place in my heart. I lead with “In Bruges” because McDonagh’s newest film, “Wild Horse Nine”, has a shockingly similar list of ingredients: a zippy brand of witty dialogue, themes of suicide, and compassion, the spolighting of a niche location, and an odd fascination with dwarves.
The story is set in Chile, late into 1973. CIA operatives Chris Carlisle (John Malkovich) and Lee Chesterfield (Sam Rockwell) depart their field office in Santiago to go on a weeklong vacation to Easter Island. Their friendship is that of classic All-American pals, as reflected by the candor and jocularity of their acerbic conversations. Perhaps it helps that they are both engaged in the work of "destabilizing” a foreign democracy. This is one of the recurring jokes in the film. Both Chris and Lee treat regime change (and the blood that comes from it) with a cavalier attitude. These are not the deadly serious CIA agents you find in most spy movies. Their station chief in Santiago is a pasty slimeball named MJ (Steve Buscemi), who is incessantly worried about a memoir that Chris is intending to write. In the opening sequence, we learn that Chris has been intimately involved with all the greatest hits of the wild-west CIA of the 1950’s, 60’s, and 70’s; from Guatemala and Jacobo Árbenz up to Chile and Salvador Allende. The plot also treats a certain JFK conspiracy theory as fact. Chris was boots on the ground for the “Dallas operation”, and is assumed to be holding onto some souvenirs from the assassination. Much like Fiennes’ character from “In Bruges”, we see MJ mostly during phone conversations, with his role only expanding at the conclusion.
Depending on who you are, both Chris and Lee will come off as either lovable or despicable. Or maybe both. They are individuals that are comfortable doing the dirty work. They are utilitarianists, or perhaps consequentialists. Much of the best dialogue is borne out of these mindsets. Chris and Lee can joke about killing and coup d'état, which makes other jokes about less serious topics land with a special kind of levity. It works. For example, in one scene Chris muses about the correlation between “gay countries” and a fine selection of local cheeses, which Lee connects to major Western Democracies having the best cheeses. Chris gesticulates a diagram: “Democracy leads to gay, leads to cheeses”. In another scene, Chris critiques a rather shabby looking Moai (Easter Island Head), and presumes it was a Rapa Nui pity project given to a mental retard or a dwarf. These scenes, and many more like them, are a riot. I am not a big theater cackler, but found myself chuckling through the lion’s share of scenes.
This being McDonagh, there are much darker themes at work throughout the story, which build to a quite violent crescendo. If you’ve seen “In Bruges”, then you may be able to infer the core tension at the heart of “Wild Horse Nine”. I won’t give it away here. But the trip to Easter Island has much greater stakes than simple leisure time. Though I still prefer the Gleeson + Farrell + Fiennes combo to Malkovich + Rockwell + Buscemi, “Wild Horse Nine” is a better film than “In Bruges”. No scene is wasted and all the “side-plots” come full circle. There are stupendous bit parts from Indie Royalty, Tom Waits and Parker Posey, to boot. It’s a “great hang movie”, and sits right up there with “The Drama” among the best I’ve seen this year at the theater.
Highlight of the Game: Any one of Chris’ ridiculous ramblings could take this category. I might choose Chris’ presumption that his boss, MJ, is a heroin junkie as the highlight. With most of Chris’ musings, Lee reacts with valid skepticism. Sam Rockwell is especially good at these types of “Swaggy P Meme” reactions. The “MJ is a junkie” accusation comes early on in the movie, and Chris’ reasoning is especially thin. It seems like a throwaway bit of dialogue, but works its way back into the story with peak wit.
Player of the Game: If this were an “In Bruges” review, it would be Bruges, Belgium, with its many many alcoves and abundance of medieval architecture. For “Wild Horse Nine”, it is Easter Island. How many of you, dear readers, have been there? I would assume none. Do you know anyone that’s been? Probably not. It’s a special kind of location because of its wide notoriety (because of the Moai), paired with its extreme remoteness. Between the Moai, the wild horses, the grassy plains, and the 70’s resort bungalows, Easter Island gives the film an invaluable aura.
Costly Turnovers: I have no complaints with the actual movie. However, the theatrical trailer for “Wild Horse Nine” is not good, and will likely not spur you to the box office. The film is dialogue driven and shines through its character development. Neither of these qualities are primed for teasers.
